1 00:00:02,235 --> 00:00:04,371 (intro to "In the Air Tonight" by Phil Collins playing) 2 00:00:04,437 --> 00:00:07,107 (crowd chatter low and distant) 3 00:00:09,209 --> 00:00:11,211 (distant cheering) 4 00:00:24,391 --> 00:00:26,292 ♪ I can feel it ♪ 5 00:00:26,359 --> 00:00:31,097 ♪ Coming in the air tonight ♪ 6 00:00:31,164 --> 00:00:33,166 ♪ Oh, Lord ♪ 7 00:00:34,434 --> 00:00:37,537 ♪ And I've been waiting for this moment ♪ 8 00:00:37,604 --> 00:00:40,440 ♪ For all my life ♪ 9 00:00:40,507 --> 00:00:43,176 ♪ Oh, Lord ♪ 10 00:00:45,178 --> 00:00:46,513 ♪ Can you feel it ♪ 11 00:00:46,579 --> 00:00:51,117 ♪ Coming in the air tonight? ♪ 12 00:00:51,184 --> 00:00:53,219 ♪ Oh, Lord ♪ 13 00:00:54,320 --> 00:00:56,289 ♪ Oh, Lord ♪ 14 00:00:59,359 --> 00:01:01,294 (crowd chatter continues low and distant) 15 00:01:01,361 --> 00:01:04,129 ♪ ♪ 16 00:01:04,197 --> 00:01:08,134 ♪ Well, if you told me you were drowning... ♪ 17 00:01:08,201 --> 00:01:10,203 (music stops) 18 00:01:31,458 --> 00:01:34,093 (line ringing) 19 00:01:34,160 --> 00:01:37,430 WOMAN (over phone): 911. What's your emergency? 20 00:01:37,497 --> 00:01:40,200 Hello? 21 00:01:40,266 --> 00:01:42,168 911. What's your emergency? 22 00:01:42,235 --> 00:01:43,703 Hello? Is anyone there? 23 00:01:43,770 --> 00:01:45,205 (woman moaning weakly) 24 00:01:45,271 --> 00:01:47,140 Sir? Ma'am? 25 00:01:47,207 --> 00:01:49,142 Are you there? 26 00:01:49,209 --> 00:01:50,477 Stay on the line, please. 27 00:01:50,543 --> 00:01:52,612 I'm sending someone to this number. 28 00:01:52,679 --> 00:01:54,514 Are you still there? 29 00:01:54,581 --> 00:01:54,581 Sir? 30 00:01:54,581 --> 00:01:56,516 (music resumes playing) 31 00:01:56,583 --> 00:01:56,583 Ma'am? 32 00:01:56,583 --> 00:01:59,319 ♪ I've been waiting for this moment ♪ 33 00:01:59,385 --> 00:02:02,121 ♪ For all my life ♪ 34 00:02:02,188 --> 00:02:04,524 ♪ Oh, Lord ♪ 35 00:02:05,725 --> 00:02:07,527 ♪ Can you feel it ♪ 36 00:02:07,594 --> 00:02:12,131 ♪ Coming in the air tonight? ♪ 37 00:02:12,198 --> 00:02:14,567 ♪ Oh, Lord ♪ 38 00:02:15,702 --> 00:02:19,205 ♪ I've been waiting for this moment ♪ 39 00:02:19,272 --> 00:02:21,274 ♪ For all my life ♪ 40 00:02:22,575 --> 00:02:24,310 ♪ Oh, Lord ♪ 41 00:02:25,345 --> 00:02:29,349 ♪ Oh, Lord... ♪ 42 00:02:29,415 --> 00:02:31,551 (weak, raspy breathing) 43 00:02:40,460 --> 00:02:42,562 Check the vics. Call it in. 44 00:02:48,434 --> 00:02:50,436 (raspy breath) 45 00:02:54,240 --> 00:02:56,609 Central, I've got one DOA, one heavy bleeder 46 00:02:56,676 --> 00:02:57,944 at 232 Hillside Avenue. 47 00:02:58,011 --> 00:02:59,612 Need an ambulance now. 48 00:02:59,679 --> 00:03:01,648 WOMAN (over radio): Copy that. Ambulance and... 49 00:03:01,714 --> 00:03:04,183 (music continues, drums play rock beat) 50 00:03:04,250 --> 00:03:05,585 ♪ I can feel it ♪ 51 00:03:05,652 --> 00:03:09,389 ♪ Coming in the air tonight ♪ 52 00:03:10,523 --> 00:03:13,526 ♪ Oh, Lord ♪ 53 00:03:14,661 --> 00:03:17,363 ♪ Well, I've been waiting for this moment ♪ 54 00:03:17,430 --> 00:03:19,766 ♪ For all my life ♪ 55 00:03:21,467 --> 00:03:23,536 ♪ Oh, Lord... ♪ 56 00:03:24,604 --> 00:03:25,805 (music fades out) 57 00:03:27,440 --> 00:03:30,510 Mrs. Travers, I'm Detective Mac Taylor. 58 00:03:30,577 --> 00:03:33,246 If you can hear me, I need you to raise your finger. 59 00:03:33,313 --> 00:03:35,348 Can you do that? 60 00:03:35,415 --> 00:03:36,583 Good. Good. 61 00:03:36,649 --> 00:03:38,418 I'm going to ask you a couple of questions. 62 00:03:38,484 --> 00:03:41,321 If the answer is yes, I need you to move your finger up and down. 63 00:03:41,387 --> 00:03:42,589 If the answer is no, 64 00:03:42,655 --> 00:03:43,556 move it side to side. 65 00:03:43,623 --> 00:03:45,458 Do you understand me? 66 00:03:45,525 --> 00:03:48,261 Good. Good. 67 00:03:48,328 --> 00:03:50,229 Do you know the person who did this to you? 68 00:03:52,632 --> 00:03:54,367 Was there a guest in the house tonight? 69 00:03:57,070 --> 00:03:58,304 When you guys arrived, 70 00:03:58,371 --> 00:03:59,539 was there any sign of forced entry? 71 00:03:59,606 --> 00:04:01,407 No, sir. 72 00:04:01,474 --> 00:04:05,612 Mrs. Travers, did someone in your family do this to you? 73 00:04:09,082 --> 00:04:11,351 Give me that picture over there. 74 00:04:11,417 --> 00:04:13,686 Right there. Come on. Come on. 75 00:04:15,622 --> 00:04:17,523 Mrs. Travers, I need you to listen 76 00:04:17,589 --> 00:04:18,423 very carefully. 77 00:04:19,625 --> 00:04:21,594 Is this the person who did this to you? 78 00:04:24,397 --> 00:04:25,632 (moans weakly) 79 00:04:28,768 --> 00:04:30,536 Is this your son? 80 00:04:30,603 --> 00:04:32,472 Did your son do this to you? 81 00:04:32,538 --> 00:04:35,742 (groaning weakly) 82 00:04:36,776 --> 00:04:38,611 We got to find this kid right away. 83 00:04:48,821 --> 00:04:52,725 Captioning sponsored by CBS, 84 00:04:52,792 --> 00:05:02,769 CSI NY PRODUCTIONS, 85 00:05:02,835 --> 00:05:08,808 CSI NY PRODUCTIONS, 86 00:05:08,875 --> 00:05:13,346 ♪ Out here in the fields ♪ 87 00:05:13,413 --> 00:05:17,083 ♪ I fight for my meals ♪ 88 00:05:17,150 --> 00:05:21,821 ♪ I get my back into my living ♪ 89 00:05:23,990 --> 00:05:26,426 ♪ Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. ♪ 90 00:05:34,000 --> 00:05:35,902 (siren wailing) 91 00:05:35,968 --> 00:05:38,871 (hip-hop music playing) 92 00:05:44,477 --> 00:05:46,813 ♪ Let me ooze into your earhole ♪ 93 00:05:46,879 --> 00:05:48,815 ♪ Hold still, dear, don't be fearful ♪ 94 00:05:48,881 --> 00:05:50,450 ♪ What I got gonna make you cheerful ♪ 95 00:05:50,516 --> 00:05:52,385 ♪ Party, party, best prepare, oh ♪ 96 00:05:52,452 --> 00:05:54,654 ♪ My, my, got to get you sky-high ♪ 97 00:05:54,721 --> 00:05:56,689 ♪ Birds fly by, eyes in midflight ♪ 98 00:05:56,756 --> 00:05:58,558 ♪ Well, then I got something you might try ♪ 99 00:05:58,624 --> 00:05:59,859 ♪ Testify body movements is drum tight ♪ 100 00:05:59,926 --> 00:06:01,828 ♪ The old boy stay sure you stay sore ♪ 101 00:06:01,894 --> 00:06:03,696 ♪ I adore you and all your damn flaws ♪ 102 00:06:03,763 --> 00:06:05,965 ♪ Fire can handle this, scandalous ♪ 103 00:06:06,032 --> 00:06:07,900 ♪ Ample examples of heat, the people freak, saying ♪ 104 00:06:07,967 --> 00:06:09,936 ♪ Those hot, bright lights ♪ 105 00:06:10,002 --> 00:06:11,971 ♪ Big nights, this how your love is ♪ 106 00:06:12,038 --> 00:06:14,574 ♪ Hot days, hot days, all right ♪ 107 00:06:14,640 --> 00:06:16,142 ♪ This how your love is ♪ 108 00:06:16,209 --> 00:06:18,611 ♪ Bright lights, big nights ♪ 109 00:06:18,678 --> 00:06:20,713 ♪ This how your love is... ♪ 110 00:06:20,780 --> 00:06:20,780 Police. 111 00:06:20,780 --> 00:06:22,615 (groans) 112 00:06:22,682 --> 00:06:22,682 What are you doing? 113 00:06:22,682 --> 00:06:24,000 What the hell, man? 114 00:06:24,000 --> 00:06:24,000 What are you doing? 115 00:06:24,000 --> 00:06:24,383 What the hell, man? 116 00:06:24,450 --> 00:06:26,753 Leave him alone. What the hell is the matter with you? 117 00:06:26,819 --> 00:06:26,819 (handcuffs clicking) 118 00:06:26,819 --> 00:06:27,854 Let go of me! 119 00:06:27,920 --> 00:06:29,689 Billy Travers, you're under arrest 120 00:06:29,756 --> 00:06:31,591 for the murder of your father, Walter Travers, 121 00:06:31,657 --> 00:06:33,426 and the attempted murder 122 00:06:33,493 --> 00:06:34,861 of your mother, Grace Travers. 123 00:06:34,927 --> 00:06:34,927 What? 124 00:06:34,927 --> 00:06:36,000 That's right, buddy. She's still alive. 125 00:06:36,000 --> 00:06:36,000 What? 126 00:06:36,000 --> 00:06:36,863 That's right, buddy. She's still alive. 127 00:06:36,929 --> 00:06:38,397 What are you talking about? 128 00:06:38,464 --> 00:06:38,464 Let's go. 129 00:06:38,464 --> 00:06:39,999 Billy! 130 00:06:40,066 --> 00:06:41,000 (crowd murmuring) 131 00:06:41,067 --> 00:06:42,769 Where are you taking him? 132 00:06:42,835 --> 00:06:43,903 Get off me! 133 00:06:43,970 --> 00:06:45,671 ♪ You don't need no help ♪ 134 00:06:45,738 --> 00:06:46,873 Billy! 135 00:06:46,939 --> 00:06:49,609 ♪ You don't need no help, get up, do that yourself... ♪ 136 00:06:49,675 --> 00:06:51,477 She was communicative at the scene. 137 00:06:51,544 --> 00:06:52,678 AAO times three. Following commands. 138 00:06:52,745 --> 00:06:53,980 Mental status decreased in transit. 139 00:06:54,046 --> 00:06:55,948 Shallow breathing. Dropped her sats. 140 00:06:56,015 --> 00:06:57,750 Required bagging. 141 00:06:57,817 --> 00:06:59,852 Get me an airway box, 7.5 ET tube 142 00:06:59,919 --> 00:06:59,919 (alarm beeping) 143 00:06:59,919 --> 00:07:00,000 and call for respiratory. 144 00:07:00,000 --> 00:07:00,000 (alarm beeping) 145 00:07:00,000 --> 00:07:02,455 and call for respiratory. 146 00:07:02,522 --> 00:07:02,522 She's arresting! 147 00:07:02,522 --> 00:07:03,956 I need a BBM. 148 00:07:04,023 --> 00:07:05,491 Drop her head down, please. 149 00:07:05,558 --> 00:07:07,960 (alarm continues beeping) 150 00:07:16,569 --> 00:07:18,771 (camera shutter clicking) 151 00:07:20,039 --> 00:07:23,042 (indistinct radio transmissions) 152 00:07:23,109 --> 00:07:25,444 Remember what I said about having a son? 153 00:07:25,511 --> 00:07:25,511 Yeah. 154 00:07:25,511 --> 00:07:26,779 Never mind. 155 00:07:26,846 --> 00:07:28,447 I'm good. 156 00:07:28,514 --> 00:07:29,482 Start from the outside in? 157 00:07:29,549 --> 00:07:30,316 Yeah. 158 00:07:30,383 --> 00:07:32,018 We got to eliminate any prints left 159 00:07:32,084 --> 00:07:33,519 by the first officers and the EMTs. 160 00:07:33,586 --> 00:07:34,687 HAWKES: And Mac. 161 00:07:34,754 --> 00:07:36,989 Be honest. If that was you who responded to the scene, 162 00:07:37,056 --> 00:07:38,925 would you have known to try to get an I.D. 163 00:07:38,991 --> 00:07:40,526 by asking her to move her finger up and down? 164 00:07:40,593 --> 00:07:41,727 DANNY: Probably not. 165 00:07:41,794 --> 00:07:42,929 I guess that's why he's the boss, huh? 166 00:07:42,995 --> 00:07:44,463 He wanted us to verify 167 00:07:44,530 --> 00:07:45,665 there was no forced entry. 168 00:07:45,731 --> 00:07:46,866 You want to take 169 00:07:46,933 --> 00:07:48,534 the front door, or you want the bedroom? 170 00:07:48,601 --> 00:07:49,836 I'll leave the bedroom to you two. 171 00:07:51,604 --> 00:07:52,805 Thanks. 172 00:07:52,872 --> 00:07:54,006 Bed or Floor? 173 00:07:54,073 --> 00:07:55,074 I'll take the floor. 174 00:07:56,876 --> 00:07:58,945 (camera shutter clicking) 175 00:07:59,011 --> 00:08:01,714 ("Paradise Circus" by Massive Attack playing) 176 00:08:11,724 --> 00:08:13,993 ♪ It's unfortunate ♪ 177 00:08:14,060 --> 00:08:18,831 ♪ That when we feel a storm ♪ 178 00:08:18,898 --> 00:08:21,601 ♪ We can roll ourselves over ♪ 179 00:08:21,667 --> 00:08:24,604 ♪ 'Cause we're uncomfortable ♪ 180 00:08:25,838 --> 00:08:28,574 ♪ Oh, well ♪ 181 00:08:28,641 --> 00:08:30,843 ♪ The Devil makes us sin ♪ 182 00:08:33,044 --> 00:08:36,948 ♪ But we like it when we're spinning ♪ 183 00:08:38,150 --> 00:08:41,020 ♪ In his grin ♪ 184 00:09:00,072 --> 00:09:02,141 ♪ ♪ 185 00:09:28,868 --> 00:09:30,870 (music fades) 186 00:09:32,872 --> 00:09:34,040 I don't believe you. 187 00:09:34,106 --> 00:09:35,641 Believe it, Billy. 188 00:09:35,708 --> 00:09:37,009 Your own mother identified you. 189 00:09:37,076 --> 00:09:37,076 That's not possible. 190 00:09:37,076 --> 00:09:39,011 Why? 191 00:09:39,078 --> 00:09:40,112 Because you thought she was dead? 192 00:09:40,179 --> 00:09:41,747 You left no witnesses? 193 00:09:41,814 --> 00:09:43,182 Because I didn't do anything. 194 00:09:44,150 --> 00:09:46,052 No. You're lying. 195 00:09:46,118 --> 00:09:47,186 You're lying. She didn't... 196 00:09:47,253 --> 00:09:48,921 I wish to God I was lying. 197 00:09:48,988 --> 00:09:50,890 I've been a detective for a long time. 198 00:09:50,957 --> 00:09:53,726 This is about as bad as it gets. 199 00:09:55,895 --> 00:09:58,030 My father-- 200 00:09:58,097 --> 00:10:00,066 he's dead? 201 00:10:00,132 --> 00:10:03,736 I mean, when you got there, he was already dead? 202 00:10:06,906 --> 00:10:08,207 I don't understand. 203 00:10:08,274 --> 00:10:09,942 Why would she do this to me? 204 00:10:10,009 --> 00:10:11,610 Do this to you? 205 00:10:11,677 --> 00:10:14,680 Maybe because you beat her within an inch of her life. 206 00:10:14,747 --> 00:10:15,881 I wasn't even at the house. 207 00:10:15,948 --> 00:10:17,650 I haven't been home in over a month. 208 00:10:17,717 --> 00:10:19,885 Where is she? Can... can I see her? 209 00:10:19,952 --> 00:10:21,754 Okay, Billy. 210 00:10:21,821 --> 00:10:24,857 Let's not draw this out into a Lifetime special. 211 00:10:24,924 --> 00:10:27,093 Just tell me why you did it. 212 00:10:27,159 --> 00:10:28,961 I love my parents. 213 00:10:29,028 --> 00:10:30,863 I didn't do this. 214 00:10:30,930 --> 00:10:32,865 Okay. 215 00:10:32,932 --> 00:10:34,633 Tell me again-- 216 00:10:34,700 --> 00:10:36,235 where were you today? 217 00:10:36,302 --> 00:10:37,970 And start from the beginning. 218 00:10:38,037 --> 00:10:39,238 I already told you. 219 00:10:39,305 --> 00:10:39,305 Tell me again. 220 00:10:39,305 --> 00:10:41,073 I'm not an idiot. 221 00:10:41,140 --> 00:10:42,908 You want me to tell you again because you think 222 00:10:42,975 --> 00:10:43,976 I'm going to say something different. 223 00:10:44,043 --> 00:10:45,044 You're only going to say 224 00:10:45,111 --> 00:10:46,112 something different if you're lying. 225 00:10:46,178 --> 00:10:47,179 Well, I'm not. 226 00:10:47,246 --> 00:10:48,814 Well, then, this should be easy. 227 00:10:51,183 --> 00:10:54,120 We went to a vintage clothing store on St. Marx. 228 00:10:54,186 --> 00:10:55,721 Billy wanted to get a gray jacket 229 00:10:55,788 --> 00:10:57,957 exactly like the one Tom Cruise had in the movie. 230 00:10:58,024 --> 00:11:00,059 What time was that? Be specific. 231 00:11:00,126 --> 00:11:01,660 He didn't do it. 232 00:11:01,727 --> 00:11:04,196 He doesn't have it in him to do something like this. 233 00:11:04,263 --> 00:11:07,166 Okay, Jules, I'm going to let you in on a little secret. 234 00:11:07,233 --> 00:11:09,802 Everyone has it in them to do something like this. 235 00:11:09,869 --> 00:11:09,869 Everyone. 236 00:11:09,869 --> 00:11:11,437 No. 237 00:11:11,504 --> 00:11:13,439 Not Billy. 238 00:11:13,506 --> 00:11:13,506 How long have you been going out? 239 00:11:13,506 --> 00:11:15,241 Five months. 240 00:11:15,307 --> 00:11:16,208 Five months? 241 00:11:16,275 --> 00:11:20,246 I usually like to wait at least six months 242 00:11:20,312 --> 00:11:24,183 before I can attest to somebody's lack of homicidal tendencies. 243 00:11:24,250 --> 00:11:27,186 You're kind of a bitch, you know that? 244 00:11:28,888 --> 00:11:31,090 Where did you go after the clothing store? 245 00:11:31,157 --> 00:11:32,691 Back to Jules' room. 246 00:11:32,758 --> 00:11:34,960 We hung out there until around 5:00 or something, 247 00:11:35,027 --> 00:11:36,962 and then I had to go get stuff for the party. 248 00:11:37,029 --> 00:11:37,029 What stuff? 249 00:11:37,029 --> 00:11:39,899 Alcohol. I had to get a bunch of alcohol, 250 00:11:39,965 --> 00:11:42,234 so we went to the store on the corner of Bleeker... 251 00:11:42,301 --> 00:11:43,202 ...and West Third. 252 00:11:43,269 --> 00:11:44,203 Did anyone else go with you? 253 00:11:44,270 --> 00:11:46,038 I already told you no. 254 00:11:46,105 --> 00:11:47,907 Where'd you go after that? 255 00:11:47,973 --> 00:11:51,210 To the frat house to drop off the alcohol. 256 00:11:51,277 --> 00:11:53,212 That was around 7:00, maybe a little after. 257 00:11:53,279 --> 00:11:54,080 Jules go in with you? 258 00:11:54,146 --> 00:11:57,316 No. I told you we split up after that. 259 00:11:57,383 --> 00:12:00,252 So you don't know where Billy was from the time 260 00:12:00,319 --> 00:12:03,089 you left the clothing store right up until the party? 261 00:12:03,155 --> 00:12:03,155 Did you get any phone calls or texts from him? 262 00:12:03,155 --> 00:12:05,858 JULES: No. 263 00:12:05,925 --> 00:12:07,860 What time did you get to the party? 264 00:12:07,927 --> 00:12:08,961 Maybe 11:00. 265 00:12:09,028 --> 00:12:09,028 Was Billy already there when you got there? 266 00:12:09,028 --> 00:12:12,000 Yes. 267 00:12:12,000 --> 00:12:12,000 Was Billy already there when you got there? 268 00:12:12,000 --> 00:12:12,031 Yes. 269 00:12:12,098 --> 00:12:13,332 DANVILLE: So from about 8:00 to 11:00, 270 00:12:13,399 --> 00:12:15,201 I'm just supposed to take your word for it 271 00:12:15,267 --> 00:12:16,068 that you were in your room? 272 00:12:16,135 --> 00:12:18,204 And the only person who can account 273 00:12:18,270 --> 00:12:21,140 for your whereabouts earlier that day is your girlfriend. 274 00:12:22,942 --> 00:12:24,076 What are you doing? 275 00:12:24,910 --> 00:12:26,212 Math. 276 00:12:26,278 --> 00:12:28,948 Because you're not man enough to admit what you did. 277 00:12:29,014 --> 00:12:31,050 Now I gotta do math. 278 00:12:31,117 --> 00:12:32,151 I hate math. 279 00:12:32,218 --> 00:12:35,855 Half hour by train to get to your parents' place. 280 00:12:35,921 --> 00:12:41,327 25 minutes to stand outside and build the courage to kill them. 281 00:12:41,393 --> 00:12:45,898 Another 40 minutes inside to do the deed and change your clothes. 282 00:12:45,965 --> 00:12:48,801 15 minutes to puke 283 00:12:48,868 --> 00:12:52,304 and then find a place to ditch the bloody clothes. 284 00:12:52,371 --> 00:12:56,275 Another half hour to travel to your room. 285 00:12:56,342 --> 00:12:59,378 Five... ten... carry one... 286 00:12:59,445 --> 00:13:02,548 Two hours and 20 minutes, give or take. 287 00:13:02,615 --> 00:13:04,950 Plenty of time for you to commit the murder 288 00:13:05,017 --> 00:13:06,819 and get back to your room. 289 00:13:08,888 --> 00:13:11,223 You have between now and trial to fabricate a witness 290 00:13:11,290 --> 00:13:14,193 who claims to have seen you during that time. 291 00:13:20,166 --> 00:13:22,101 SID: The human skull is composed of 292 00:13:22,168 --> 00:13:25,104 one of the most durable substances found in nature. 293 00:13:25,171 --> 00:13:27,273 It takes approximately one ton 294 00:13:27,339 --> 00:13:30,376 to reduce the diameter of the skull by one centimeter. 295 00:13:30,442 --> 00:13:32,411 Unfortunately for Walter Travers, when you get 296 00:13:32,478 --> 00:13:33,345 whacked in the head 297 00:13:33,412 --> 00:13:35,381 multiple times with a blunt-force object, 298 00:13:35,447 --> 00:13:37,283 that doesn't mean a whole lot. 299 00:13:37,349 --> 00:13:38,884 Can you tell us anything 300 00:13:38,951 --> 00:13:40,886 about the nature of the blunt-force object? 301 00:13:44,990 --> 00:13:46,192 Sid? 302 00:13:46,258 --> 00:13:49,028 Oh, sorry. (awkward chuckle) 303 00:13:49,094 --> 00:13:52,298 Yeah. I-I just wasn't prepared for you to be so... 304 00:13:52,364 --> 00:13:53,399 Female? 305 00:13:53,465 --> 00:13:55,034 Right. 306 00:13:55,100 --> 00:13:58,270 Um... you see these two horizontal marks? 307 00:13:58,337 --> 00:13:59,138 They're puncture wounds. 308 00:13:59,205 --> 00:14:01,307 They speak to the nature of the weapon? 309 00:14:01,373 --> 00:14:03,275 Oh, yeah. I mean possibly. 310 00:14:03,342 --> 00:14:05,344 Let's take a look. 311 00:14:08,480 --> 00:14:08,480 You came from D.C., right? 312 00:14:08,480 --> 00:14:10,316 Yeah. 313 00:14:10,382 --> 00:14:12,451 It's an interesting town. 314 00:14:12,518 --> 00:14:14,053 I've only been there once 315 00:14:14,119 --> 00:14:15,087 to testify before Congress. 316 00:14:15,154 --> 00:14:18,057 Oh, on behalf of the National Academy of Sciences? 317 00:14:18,123 --> 00:14:19,892 Oh, no, no. I was there to testify 318 00:14:19,959 --> 00:14:21,160 that they have no business 319 00:14:21,227 --> 00:14:23,028 restructuring the College Bowl system. 320 00:14:23,095 --> 00:14:24,897 I never got past the door. 321 00:14:24,964 --> 00:14:28,867 But the town is-is quite... lovely. 322 00:14:29,935 --> 00:14:31,270 Okay. 323 00:14:31,337 --> 00:14:33,439 I, uh, put time of death 324 00:14:33,505 --> 00:14:36,308 at somewhere between 9:00 and 10:00 based on liver temp. 325 00:14:36,375 --> 00:14:37,409 He was probably knocked unconscious 326 00:14:37,476 --> 00:14:39,044 and bled out immediately, 327 00:14:39,111 --> 00:14:42,348 which would put the attack around the same time. 328 00:14:42,414 --> 00:14:44,049 SID: Here we go. 329 00:14:46,485 --> 00:14:48,354 See here? 330 00:14:48,420 --> 00:14:50,322 DANVILLE: Appear to be equal in size, 331 00:14:50,389 --> 00:14:51,924 one directly in line with the other. 332 00:14:51,991 --> 00:14:53,325 Hammer... crowbar... 333 00:14:53,392 --> 00:14:53,392 maybe? 334 00:14:53,392 --> 00:14:54,000 Or a tire iron. 335 00:14:54,000 --> 00:14:54,000 maybe? 336 00:14:54,000 --> 00:14:55,327 Or a tire iron. 337 00:14:55,394 --> 00:14:56,462 Those are the only puncture wounds? 338 00:14:56,528 --> 00:14:59,465 Yeah. And I've seen Grace Travers' hospital records. 339 00:14:59,531 --> 00:15:01,367 She suffered no punctures. 340 00:15:01,433 --> 00:15:03,469 Odds are against Billy dropping one object 341 00:15:03,535 --> 00:15:05,337 and stabbing with another, don't you think? 342 00:15:05,404 --> 00:15:07,239 Well, more than likely, the weapon 343 00:15:07,306 --> 00:15:09,041 was used as a blunt-force object 344 00:15:09,108 --> 00:15:12,311 but contained two identical, horizontal edges at the end. 345 00:15:12,378 --> 00:15:14,213 So, basically, we're looking 346 00:15:14,280 --> 00:15:16,382 for something with a claw on the end? 347 00:15:16,448 --> 00:15:17,983 A claw, right. 348 00:15:23,255 --> 00:15:25,190 Is the mother gonna make it? 349 00:15:25,257 --> 00:15:26,425 She's not conscious yet, 350 00:15:26,492 --> 00:15:28,227 but the doctors say she'll pull through. 351 00:15:28,294 --> 00:15:29,428 It's nothing short of a miracle. 352 00:15:29,495 --> 00:15:33,499 I've never seen anyone take a beating like that and survive. 353 00:15:33,565 --> 00:15:35,134 I wonder if I'd even want to. 354 00:15:35,200 --> 00:15:36,335 How do you go through life knowing 355 00:15:36,402 --> 00:15:39,138 your kid killed his father and tried his best to kill you? 356 00:15:39,204 --> 00:15:40,973 You check into his alibi? 357 00:15:41,040 --> 00:15:41,907 He essentially has no alibi. 358 00:15:41,974 --> 00:15:43,509 He was with his girlfriend most of the day, 359 00:15:43,575 --> 00:15:45,110 and that'll get ripped apart on cross. 360 00:15:45,177 --> 00:15:46,945 He claims he was in his room alone 361 00:15:47,012 --> 00:15:48,514 between 8:00 to 11:00 p.m. 362 00:15:48,580 --> 00:15:51,050 Sid puts the attack between 9:00 and 10:00. 363 00:15:51,116 --> 00:15:52,251 It's pretty convenient for him 364 00:15:52,318 --> 00:15:54,386 to claim he was alone and plenty of time 365 00:15:54,453 --> 00:15:56,322 for him to get back in time for the party. 366 00:15:56,388 --> 00:15:58,223 It'd be nice to have motive, but I guess the I.D. 367 00:15:58,290 --> 00:16:00,192 by his mother should carry a lot of weight. 368 00:16:00,259 --> 00:16:01,260 We'll need more. 369 00:16:01,327 --> 00:16:02,394 It'll take a while to analyze 370 00:16:02,461 --> 00:16:03,429 all the evidence from the scene, 371 00:16:03,495 --> 00:16:04,430 but it's hard to believe 372 00:16:04,496 --> 00:16:06,332 he didn't leave something behind. 373 00:16:06,398 --> 00:16:08,133 I just hope he pleads guilty 374 00:16:08,200 --> 00:16:10,135 and doesn't make the mother take the stand 375 00:16:10,202 --> 00:16:12,137 and have to I.D. him again in court. 376 00:16:12,204 --> 00:16:13,272 FLACK: Hey, guys. 377 00:16:13,339 --> 00:16:15,274 We got a confession. 378 00:16:15,341 --> 00:16:16,442 But not from Billy Travers. 379 00:16:16,508 --> 00:16:18,077 Guy over at Rikers 380 00:16:18,143 --> 00:16:20,212 says his cell mate confessed to killing a couple 381 00:16:20,279 --> 00:16:22,281 in their sleep last night. 382 00:16:32,391 --> 00:16:35,461 FLACK: The guy on the left is Owen Hicks. 383 00:16:35,527 --> 00:16:38,063 He's over at Rikers awaiting trial for rob one. 384 00:16:38,130 --> 00:16:40,566 Now, he says he got a new cell mate last night 385 00:16:40,632 --> 00:16:43,202 who confessed to killing a couple over in Jamaica Estates. 386 00:16:43,268 --> 00:16:44,770 Burg two, burg three, 387 00:16:44,837 --> 00:16:46,205 criminal trespassing, 388 00:16:46,271 --> 00:16:48,607 at least four drug possession arrests. 389 00:16:48,674 --> 00:16:50,609 Steals from the rich to feed his poor drug habit. 390 00:16:50,676 --> 00:16:52,578 He's looking at serious time on his current charge. 391 00:16:52,644 --> 00:16:53,479 What does he want? 392 00:16:53,545 --> 00:16:54,346 What they all want. 393 00:16:54,413 --> 00:16:55,581 A free pass. 394 00:16:55,647 --> 00:16:57,583 The guy on the right is Manny Ravarra. 395 00:16:57,649 --> 00:16:59,518 He's doing life upstate at Fishkill 396 00:16:59,585 --> 00:17:01,120 for selling drugs at schools. 397 00:17:01,186 --> 00:17:02,621 He even recruited a couple 12 year-olds 398 00:17:02,688 --> 00:17:04,189 to run a few corners for him. 399 00:17:04,256 --> 00:17:05,523 What's he doing at Rikers? 400 00:17:05,590 --> 00:17:07,059 Two weeks ago, Ravarra escaped. 401 00:17:07,126 --> 00:17:08,560 He was picked up last night, 402 00:17:08,627 --> 00:17:10,194 trying to boost a car on Jamaica Avenue. 403 00:17:10,262 --> 00:17:11,262 They run him for warrants, 404 00:17:11,329 --> 00:17:12,564 see he's an escaped convict, 405 00:17:12,631 --> 00:17:13,499 and then send him to Rikers 406 00:17:13,565 --> 00:17:15,501 until he gets transferred back upstate. 407 00:17:15,567 --> 00:17:17,269 And that's when he meets Owen Hicks? 408 00:17:17,336 --> 00:17:18,804 I find it hard to believe he'd just 409 00:17:18,871 --> 00:17:21,173 casually admit to a double homicide. 410 00:17:21,240 --> 00:17:24,076 Grace Travers looked me in the eye and I.D.'ed her killer. 411 00:17:24,143 --> 00:17:25,377 Take a ride over to Rikers. 412 00:17:25,444 --> 00:17:26,444 Bring Danny. 413 00:17:26,512 --> 00:17:28,313 See if this guy's for real. 414 00:17:36,655 --> 00:17:38,657 (buzzer sounds) 415 00:17:43,328 --> 00:17:46,131 (chains rattling) 416 00:17:48,901 --> 00:17:49,501 What I do now? 417 00:17:49,568 --> 00:17:50,602 We're here about a homicide 418 00:17:50,669 --> 00:17:53,305 that was committed last night in Jamaica Estates. 419 00:17:53,372 --> 00:17:54,573 Couple was bludgeoned to death. 420 00:17:54,640 --> 00:17:56,508 And we don't make you for it. 421 00:17:56,575 --> 00:17:58,243 In fact, we have an eyewitness who says it wasn't you. 422 00:17:58,310 --> 00:17:58,310 All right. 423 00:17:58,310 --> 00:18:00,000 But your cell mate, 424 00:18:00,000 --> 00:18:00,000 All right. 425 00:18:00,000 --> 00:18:00,212 But your cell mate, 426 00:18:00,279 --> 00:18:01,547 he says you did it. 427 00:18:01,613 --> 00:18:03,248 Said you were bragging about it. 428 00:18:03,315 --> 00:18:04,683 FLACK: But Owen Hicks is looking to get out from under 429 00:18:04,750 --> 00:18:07,286 a robbery charge that will most likely send him upstate 430 00:18:07,352 --> 00:18:09,221 for the next 15 years, so... 431 00:18:09,288 --> 00:18:10,389 Yeah, not the most reliable source. 432 00:18:10,456 --> 00:18:12,558 We figured we'd come here, lay our cards on the table, 433 00:18:12,624 --> 00:18:14,860 give you an opportunity to respond. 434 00:18:14,927 --> 00:18:16,562 Let me see if I got this right. 435 00:18:16,628 --> 00:18:18,597 My crackhead cell mate gives me up for a murder 436 00:18:18,664 --> 00:18:21,133 that an eyewitness says was committed by someone else, 437 00:18:21,200 --> 00:18:23,135 and you two drop by here to give me the opportunity 438 00:18:23,202 --> 00:18:24,570 to say that I didn't do nothing? 439 00:18:24,636 --> 00:18:25,871 I got that right? 440 00:18:25,938 --> 00:18:25,938 What about it, Manny? 441 00:18:25,938 --> 00:18:27,539 What about it? 442 00:18:29,374 --> 00:18:32,444 Sometimes crackheads actually tell the truth. 443 00:18:32,511 --> 00:18:34,179 So what are you saying? 444 00:18:34,246 --> 00:18:36,715 I'm saying your eyewitness is wrong-- I killed that couple. 445 00:18:37,649 --> 00:18:38,684 Yeah. 446 00:18:38,750 --> 00:18:40,452 I could go ahead and deny it. 447 00:18:40,519 --> 00:18:42,521 What for? 448 00:18:43,956 --> 00:18:45,390 What are you guys going to do? 449 00:18:45,457 --> 00:18:46,725 I'm already doing life in prison. 450 00:18:46,792 --> 00:18:48,727 I just escaped. 451 00:18:48,794 --> 00:18:49,561 Do you think I care about adding 452 00:18:49,628 --> 00:18:51,263 another life sentence to my term? 453 00:18:51,330 --> 00:18:52,698 Tell me what happened. 454 00:18:52,764 --> 00:18:54,600 Why'd you do it? 455 00:18:54,666 --> 00:18:56,735 What do you think? 456 00:18:56,802 --> 00:18:58,737 I was on the run. 457 00:18:58,804 --> 00:19:01,740 I figured I could make out with some jewelry. 458 00:19:01,807 --> 00:19:03,909 If I was lucky, a decent amount of cash. 459 00:19:03,976 --> 00:19:05,377 But why'd you kill the couple? 460 00:19:05,444 --> 00:19:06,478 The guy woke up while I was going through 461 00:19:06,545 --> 00:19:07,513 one of his drawers. 462 00:19:07,579 --> 00:19:09,147 And the woman? 463 00:19:09,214 --> 00:19:10,716 She wouldn't stop screaming. I mean... 464 00:19:10,782 --> 00:19:13,552 ear-piercing screaming. 465 00:19:13,619 --> 00:19:15,654 I wasn't wearing anything to cover my face, so... 466 00:19:15,721 --> 00:19:16,522 I had to do what I had to do. 467 00:19:16,588 --> 00:19:19,224 Then I got pinched for boosting a car 468 00:19:19,291 --> 00:19:20,259 before I got out of town. 469 00:19:20,325 --> 00:19:21,627 I'm not buying it. 470 00:19:21,693 --> 00:19:23,695 (chuckling) 471 00:19:25,297 --> 00:19:26,465 Is this guy for real? 472 00:19:27,699 --> 00:19:29,568 Great. I'm not buying it, either. 473 00:19:29,635 --> 00:19:30,636 Can I go now? 474 00:19:30,702 --> 00:19:31,703 I'm missing Oprah. 475 00:19:31,770 --> 00:19:33,338 (chuckles) 476 00:19:33,405 --> 00:19:35,507 None of the drawers were open, buddy. 477 00:19:35,574 --> 00:19:36,742 They weren't even rifled through, 478 00:19:36,808 --> 00:19:37,976 so what were you stealing? 479 00:19:38,043 --> 00:19:41,680 Not to mention these people were brutally, brutally beaten, 480 00:19:41,747 --> 00:19:43,649 which would suggest that this was personal, 481 00:19:43,715 --> 00:19:46,718 not that you were trying to keep them from I.D.'ing you. 482 00:19:46,785 --> 00:19:49,221 Fantastic. 483 00:19:49,288 --> 00:19:51,590 I'll make sure to tell my lawyer that when we go to trial. 484 00:19:51,657 --> 00:19:52,724 Trial? 485 00:19:52,791 --> 00:19:53,759 You're confessing to the crime. 486 00:19:53,825 --> 00:19:54,760 You think there's gonna be a trial? 487 00:19:54,826 --> 00:19:54,826 What did you kill them with? 488 00:19:54,826 --> 00:19:56,695 You testing me? 489 00:19:56,762 --> 00:19:57,796 Is this a test? 490 00:20:02,034 --> 00:20:03,569 Why don't you look in the sewer, 491 00:20:03,635 --> 00:20:06,338 at 104th Street and Lefferts Boulevard. 492 00:20:06,405 --> 00:20:08,407 Let me know if I passed. 493 00:20:08,473 --> 00:20:10,442 (buzzer sounds, door opens) 494 00:20:14,613 --> 00:20:18,283 ♪ I'm falling apart again ♪ 495 00:20:23,855 --> 00:20:26,258 ♪ I expected more but ♪ 496 00:20:26,325 --> 00:20:30,362 ♪ You get what you put in ♪ 497 00:20:30,429 --> 00:20:34,366 ♪ Spoken words all gone now ♪ 498 00:20:34,433 --> 00:20:38,003 ♪ No one here left to listen ♪ 499 00:20:38,070 --> 00:20:41,773 ♪ I'm falling apart again ♪ 500 00:20:44,810 --> 00:20:49,247 ♪ I'm falling apart again ♪ 501 00:20:49,314 --> 00:20:52,351 ♪ I'm falling apart again ♪ 502 00:20:52,417 --> 00:20:55,821 ♪ I'm falling apart again ♪ 503 00:20:55,887 --> 00:20:58,657 ♪ I'm falling apart again ♪ 504 00:21:03,829 --> 00:21:06,832 ♪ You never see it coming ♪ 505 00:21:13,872 --> 00:21:17,609 ♪ Can't accept it's over ♪ 506 00:21:17,676 --> 00:21:20,879 ♪ Just wake up from trying ♪ 507 00:21:20,946 --> 00:21:24,783 ♪ I'm falling apart again ♪ 508 00:21:24,850 --> 00:21:28,754 ♪ I'm falling apart again ♪ 509 00:21:28,820 --> 00:21:32,624 ♪ I'm falling apart again ♪ 510 00:21:32,691 --> 00:21:35,894 ♪ I'm falling apart again ♪ 511 00:21:35,961 --> 00:21:38,897 ♪ Help me find a way ♪ 512 00:21:38,964 --> 00:21:40,866 ♪ I'm lost again. ♪ 513 00:21:42,901 --> 00:21:44,903 (music fades) 514 00:21:46,438 --> 00:21:48,540 Is she able to talk? 515 00:21:48,607 --> 00:21:52,077 Look, I-I know she's been through a major trauma, 516 00:21:52,144 --> 00:21:54,479 but would it be all right if I came by to see her? 517 00:21:54,546 --> 00:21:57,449 I won't be long. I know she needs her rest. 518 00:21:57,516 --> 00:21:59,785 Great, great. I appreciate it, Doctor. 519 00:21:59,851 --> 00:22:01,787 Thank you. 520 00:22:04,489 --> 00:22:05,424 Please tell me you have something 521 00:22:05,490 --> 00:22:07,392 that puts Billy Travers at the crime scene. 522 00:22:07,459 --> 00:22:07,459 Nothing. 523 00:22:07,459 --> 00:22:09,394 Nothing on my end, either. 524 00:22:09,461 --> 00:22:12,464 LINDSEY: All the shoe impressions at the scene were from either 525 00:22:12,531 --> 00:22:13,665 the first officers or the EMTs. 526 00:22:13,732 --> 00:22:14,933 And the blood samples have been sent to DNA, 527 00:22:15,000 --> 00:22:16,935 but we were able to type them. 528 00:22:17,002 --> 00:22:19,104 None of them are a match to Billy Travers. 529 00:22:19,171 --> 00:22:20,939 The front door was definitely jimmied open. 530 00:22:21,006 --> 00:22:22,874 The first officers told me 531 00:22:22,941 --> 00:22:25,410 there was no sign of forced entry. 532 00:22:25,477 --> 00:22:26,912 Well, the majority of the damage was to the inside of the lock, 533 00:22:26,978 --> 00:22:28,547 most likely from a crowbar, which is consistent 534 00:22:28,613 --> 00:22:31,717 with the puncture wounds Sid found on Billy's father. 535 00:22:31,783 --> 00:22:33,885 And Flack said that Billy had a key to his parents' house. 536 00:22:33,952 --> 00:22:34,953 Well, he could've used the key, 537 00:22:35,020 --> 00:22:36,455 then intentionally damaged the lock 538 00:22:36,521 --> 00:22:37,889 to make it look like a break-in. 539 00:22:37,956 --> 00:22:39,091 What else? 540 00:22:39,157 --> 00:22:42,561 Well, I was able to extract microbial DNA from the soil 541 00:22:42,627 --> 00:22:44,896 that was disturbed next to the front door, but again, 542 00:22:44,963 --> 00:22:47,365 not a match to the dirt found on Billy Travers' shoes. 543 00:22:47,432 --> 00:22:49,634 All we have is the I.D. right now. 544 00:22:49,701 --> 00:22:51,703 So he was either extremely careful, 545 00:22:51,770 --> 00:22:54,606 or we have to consider that he didn't do this. 546 00:22:57,042 --> 00:22:58,677 At the scene, I thought 547 00:22:58,744 --> 00:23:00,779 that might be the only chance to talk to her. 548 00:23:00,846 --> 00:23:02,748 When they said there was no forced entry, 549 00:23:02,814 --> 00:23:04,783 that prompted me to show her a photo of her family. 550 00:23:04,850 --> 00:23:06,885 And she was responsive, right? 551 00:23:06,952 --> 00:23:09,921 She was. She looked me in the eye and understood me. 552 00:23:12,824 --> 00:23:14,960 But maybe I pushed too hard in the moment. 553 00:23:19,064 --> 00:23:22,000 I can just picture Manny Ravarra, 554 00:23:22,067 --> 00:23:24,903 sitting the cafeteria with a stupid grin on his face, 555 00:23:24,970 --> 00:23:26,638 eating a bologna sandwich, 556 00:23:26,705 --> 00:23:28,406 gloating to the other inmates 557 00:23:28,473 --> 00:23:29,975 how two mope detectives are knee-deep in crap 558 00:23:30,041 --> 00:23:32,677 for absolutely no reason. 559 00:23:32,744 --> 00:23:34,513 DANNY (echoing): Actually, I only see one mope detective 560 00:23:34,579 --> 00:23:35,881 down here. You want to join me? 561 00:23:35,947 --> 00:23:37,649 I don't do sewers. 562 00:23:37,716 --> 00:23:39,785 It's like he said-- 563 00:23:39,851 --> 00:23:41,887 he's doing life, he's got nothing to lose, 564 00:23:41,953 --> 00:23:43,755 so why not jerk us around? 565 00:23:43,822 --> 00:23:46,024 DANNY: What was it he said about crackheads? 566 00:23:46,091 --> 00:23:48,460 Sometimes they tell the truth. 567 00:23:48,860 --> 00:23:49,861 Yeah? 568 00:23:52,864 --> 00:23:55,500 Well, it might be one of those times. 569 00:23:58,703 --> 00:24:00,005 Think this Manny Ravarra guy's for real? 570 00:24:00,071 --> 00:24:01,239 One way to find out. 571 00:24:01,306 --> 00:24:03,041 You recovered trace amounts of rust from the scrape marks 572 00:24:03,108 --> 00:24:05,010 on the locks of the Travers house, right? 573 00:24:05,076 --> 00:24:05,076 It's right here. 574 00:24:05,076 --> 00:24:06,000 Nice. Great. 575 00:24:06,000 --> 00:24:06,000 It's right here. 576 00:24:06,000 --> 00:24:07,512 Nice. Great. 577 00:24:07,579 --> 00:24:09,047 You're gonna date the rust, huh? Pretty smart. 578 00:24:09,114 --> 00:24:10,115 I have my moments. 579 00:24:10,182 --> 00:24:13,785 Sample I took off the lock didn't contain magnetite. 580 00:24:13,852 --> 00:24:15,887 Right. Which means the rust is pretty damn old... 581 00:24:15,954 --> 00:24:18,223 and won't cling to steel. 582 00:24:18,290 --> 00:24:19,891 But if the magnetite 583 00:24:19,958 --> 00:24:20,959 hasn't yet completely diminished... 584 00:24:23,995 --> 00:24:26,031 Looks like Manny Ravarra's playing you. 585 00:24:26,097 --> 00:24:28,733 Why would he want to go down for a murder he didn't commit? 586 00:24:31,736 --> 00:24:33,004 (monitor beeping rhythmically) 587 00:24:33,071 --> 00:24:35,073 (knocking on door) 588 00:24:37,943 --> 00:24:39,044 TAYLOR: Mrs. Travers? 589 00:24:41,713 --> 00:24:43,548 I'm Detective Mac Taylor. 590 00:24:43,615 --> 00:24:45,784 Do you mind if I talk to you for a moment? 591 00:24:45,851 --> 00:24:47,619 Come closer. 592 00:24:49,154 --> 00:24:50,922 What did you say your name was? 593 00:24:50,989 --> 00:24:52,958 Mac Taylor. 594 00:24:53,024 --> 00:24:55,527 I'm a detective with the New York Crime Lab. 595 00:24:55,594 --> 00:24:56,862 I came to your house last night, 596 00:24:56,928 --> 00:24:58,563 after you called 911. 597 00:24:58,630 --> 00:24:59,831 I called 911? 598 00:24:59,898 --> 00:25:01,833 Yeah. 599 00:25:01,900 --> 00:25:04,870 Miraculously, you... you did. 600 00:25:04,936 --> 00:25:06,104 Somehow you found the strength 601 00:25:06,171 --> 00:25:07,572 to pick up the phone. 602 00:25:07,639 --> 00:25:08,974 It saved your life. 603 00:25:09,040 --> 00:25:11,543 They told me my husband's dead. 604 00:25:16,147 --> 00:25:19,117 Mrs. Travers, do you remember what happened last night? 605 00:25:19,184 --> 00:25:20,619 No. 606 00:25:20,685 --> 00:25:23,989 I just remember waking up in this room. 607 00:25:24,055 --> 00:25:27,759 I realize this is hard, 608 00:25:27,826 --> 00:25:30,128 but can you tell me why your son would have done this? 609 00:25:30,195 --> 00:25:32,864 Billy? 610 00:25:32,931 --> 00:25:33,899 Yes. 611 00:25:33,965 --> 00:25:35,867 You think Billy did this to me? 612 00:25:35,934 --> 00:25:39,037 Last night, you identified your son. 613 00:25:39,104 --> 00:25:40,005 To me. 614 00:25:40,071 --> 00:25:41,606 I showed you a photograph, 615 00:25:41,673 --> 00:25:43,041 and you indicated that he had done this. 616 00:25:43,108 --> 00:25:44,542 No... 617 00:25:44,609 --> 00:25:46,645 No, I did no such thing. 618 00:25:46,711 --> 00:25:49,314 No, B-Billy didn't do this. 619 00:25:49,381 --> 00:25:51,750 He would never do anything to hurt me, 620 00:25:51,816 --> 00:25:52,817 or his father. 621 00:25:52,884 --> 00:25:55,053 Mrs. Travers, I know you've been through a lot... 622 00:25:55,120 --> 00:25:56,121 Who are you? 623 00:25:56,187 --> 00:25:58,890 My name is Mac Taylor. 624 00:25:58,957 --> 00:26:00,125 Why did you come here? 625 00:26:00,191 --> 00:26:03,128 To tell me that my son did this to me? 626 00:26:03,194 --> 00:26:04,763 To tell me these lies? 627 00:26:04,829 --> 00:26:06,331 I don't want to upset you... 628 00:26:06,398 --> 00:26:07,632 No, you listen to me! 629 00:26:07,699 --> 00:26:09,768 You leave Billy alone, 630 00:26:09,834 --> 00:26:10,902 do you understand me? 631 00:26:10,969 --> 00:26:12,837 He would never do this! 632 00:26:12,904 --> 00:26:14,639 Now, go! 633 00:26:14,706 --> 00:26:16,107 Get out! 634 00:26:16,174 --> 00:26:18,576 Leave my family alone! 635 00:26:41,132 --> 00:26:42,801 TAYLOR: Sid. 636 00:26:42,867 --> 00:26:44,803 (rapid beeping) 637 00:26:44,869 --> 00:26:46,604 Ah, see that? 638 00:26:46,671 --> 00:26:48,373 A familiar face-- recognition. 639 00:26:48,440 --> 00:26:51,042 Neurons coursing through my synapses. 640 00:26:51,109 --> 00:26:52,877 What's with the pictures? 641 00:26:52,944 --> 00:26:54,045 A little experiment. 642 00:26:54,112 --> 00:26:55,146 Random photos 643 00:26:55,213 --> 00:26:57,015 of people I don't know mixed with one 644 00:26:57,082 --> 00:26:58,984 I do know. 645 00:26:59,050 --> 00:27:01,219 See? Very little activity. 646 00:27:01,286 --> 00:27:03,822 No emotional connection. 647 00:27:03,888 --> 00:27:03,888 (rapid beeping) 648 00:27:03,888 --> 00:27:05,724 TAYLOR: Oh. 649 00:27:05,790 --> 00:27:07,225 (chuckles) Off the charts. 650 00:27:07,292 --> 00:27:09,227 So, what's the emotional connection there? 651 00:27:09,294 --> 00:27:10,662 Alimony. 652 00:27:10,729 --> 00:27:12,030 (chuckles) 653 00:27:14,299 --> 00:27:16,167 Grace Travers' hospital records. 654 00:27:16,234 --> 00:27:19,971 She's clearly experiencing retrograde amnesia. 655 00:27:20,038 --> 00:27:23,108 It's very common with victims of traumatic brain injury. 656 00:27:23,174 --> 00:27:26,077 Which explains why she doesn't remember I.D.'ing her son. 657 00:27:26,144 --> 00:27:26,144 Right. 658 00:27:26,144 --> 00:27:28,413 But is the identification reliable? 659 00:27:28,480 --> 00:27:30,115 That's hard to say. 660 00:27:30,181 --> 00:27:32,150 The hospital gave me a copy 661 00:27:32,217 --> 00:27:33,818 of her MRI-- most of the damage 662 00:27:33,885 --> 00:27:36,421 occurred to the front-left temporal lobe. 663 00:27:36,488 --> 00:27:39,424 You can see a significant amount of bleeding in this area here. 664 00:27:39,491 --> 00:27:42,761 TAYLOR: Front-left controls language, speech, memory. 665 00:27:42,827 --> 00:27:43,962 Among other things, yes. 666 00:27:44,029 --> 00:27:45,163 So you think it's possible 667 00:27:45,230 --> 00:27:48,800 that her memory of the event at the time she made the I.D. 668 00:27:48,867 --> 00:27:48,867 could've been affected. 669 00:27:48,867 --> 00:27:50,135 Very possible 670 00:27:50,201 --> 00:27:51,903 if she suffered extreme brain damage. 671 00:27:51,970 --> 00:27:54,139 But she was able to understand and obey commands-- I was there. 672 00:27:54,205 --> 00:27:56,041 Same part of the brain, no? 673 00:27:56,107 --> 00:27:58,176 Well, the same area, but the effects differ. 674 00:27:58,243 --> 00:28:00,845 Language and comprehension can remain intact 675 00:28:00,912 --> 00:28:02,213 while memory is abolished. 676 00:28:02,280 --> 00:28:04,849 Sid, I showed her a photograph of her family. 677 00:28:04,916 --> 00:28:07,285 She was able to communicate with me using her finger 678 00:28:07,352 --> 00:28:08,887 that Billy did this to her. 679 00:28:08,953 --> 00:28:11,056 Oftentimes, damage to the temporal lobe 680 00:28:11,122 --> 00:28:12,190 results in seizures, 681 00:28:12,257 --> 00:28:14,025 and those seizures have a tendency 682 00:28:14,092 --> 00:28:15,293 to start in the hands. 683 00:28:15,360 --> 00:28:17,762 So it's possible the movement of her finger 684 00:28:17,829 --> 00:28:19,230 up and down was involuntary. 685 00:28:20,965 --> 00:28:23,134 You think I made a mistake showing her the photograph? 686 00:28:23,201 --> 00:28:25,003 Well, like you said, she was responsive 687 00:28:25,070 --> 00:28:26,204 and obeying commands. 688 00:28:26,271 --> 00:28:28,239 I hate to play devil's advocate here, Mac, 689 00:28:28,306 --> 00:28:31,042 but a defense attorney would have a field day with that I.D. 690 00:28:31,109 --> 00:28:32,177 Bottom line, we don't have 691 00:28:32,243 --> 00:28:34,245 a picture of what happened in her brain 692 00:28:34,312 --> 00:28:35,914 when she moved her finger. 693 00:28:35,980 --> 00:28:39,284 So there's just no way to know if her I.D. is reliable. 694 00:28:39,350 --> 00:28:41,820 And now she's defending her son. 695 00:28:43,321 --> 00:28:45,890 DANNY: So this guy, he's definitely lying. 696 00:28:45,957 --> 00:28:48,493 I mean, the rust on the crowbar he led us to isn't a match 697 00:28:48,560 --> 00:28:50,228 to the rust that we pulled from the vic's door. 698 00:28:50,295 --> 00:28:53,231 So how'd he know to lead you to a crowbar in the first place? 699 00:28:53,298 --> 00:28:54,432 How about this for timing? 700 00:28:54,499 --> 00:28:57,735 Ravarra come through the 116 last night around 2:00 a.m. 701 00:28:57,802 --> 00:29:00,238 Same time and precinct as Billy Travers. 702 00:29:00,305 --> 00:29:02,841 So Flack's going at Billy in the interrogation room, 703 00:29:02,907 --> 00:29:04,008 and Manny's sitting 704 00:29:04,075 --> 00:29:05,743 in the bullpen being processed. 705 00:29:05,810 --> 00:29:06,945 Rookie cops. 706 00:29:07,011 --> 00:29:08,780 OFFICER: You're telling me the kid in there 707 00:29:08,847 --> 00:29:08,847 hacked up his parents? 708 00:29:08,847 --> 00:29:11,015 He didn't hack 'em up. 709 00:29:11,082 --> 00:29:14,219 He beat 'em, with, like, a crowbar or a tire iron or something. 710 00:29:14,285 --> 00:29:16,254 We don't have the murder weapon. 711 00:29:16,321 --> 00:29:18,323 DANNY: And after he was processed, 712 00:29:18,389 --> 00:29:20,091 he called his girlfriend in Woodside. 713 00:29:20,158 --> 00:29:23,228 I'm guessing that he asked her to find a crowbar, 714 00:29:23,294 --> 00:29:24,796 dump it in the sewer. 715 00:29:24,863 --> 00:29:27,532 So why does a convicted felon doing life 716 00:29:27,599 --> 00:29:29,968 confess to a crime he didn't commit? 717 00:29:30,034 --> 00:29:31,903 Got me. 718 00:29:31,970 --> 00:29:34,139 I want to put him on a poly, but both our polygraph examiners 719 00:29:34,205 --> 00:29:34,205 are up in the Bronx working cases. 720 00:29:34,205 --> 00:29:36,000 Flack said 721 00:29:36,000 --> 00:29:36,000 are up in the Bronx working cases. 722 00:29:36,000 --> 00:29:36,374 Flack said 723 00:29:36,441 --> 00:29:38,109 his cell mate ratted him out, right? 724 00:29:38,176 --> 00:29:39,777 Yep. Owen Hicks, he's awaiting trial 725 00:29:39,844 --> 00:29:39,844 for rob one. 726 00:29:39,844 --> 00:29:42,000 Pull them both 727 00:29:42,000 --> 00:29:42,000 for rob one. 728 00:29:42,000 --> 00:29:42,180 Pull them both 729 00:29:42,247 --> 00:29:44,215 out of Rikers and meet me at the precinct. 730 00:29:44,282 --> 00:29:45,250 What are you thinking? 731 00:29:45,316 --> 00:29:47,218 Just meet me there. 732 00:29:47,285 --> 00:29:48,786 All right. 733 00:29:51,389 --> 00:29:53,992 (singsongy): Adam... 734 00:29:54,058 --> 00:29:56,294 What did I do? 735 00:29:57,328 --> 00:29:59,130 Mac. Hey. 736 00:29:59,197 --> 00:30:01,332 The tiny shard of glass from the bedspread, 737 00:30:01,399 --> 00:30:02,867 it's consistent with a beer bottle. 738 00:30:02,934 --> 00:30:04,369 Now, nothing unique about that, right? 739 00:30:04,435 --> 00:30:06,404 But the polyester fiber on the shard, 740 00:30:06,471 --> 00:30:07,639 it's from a security laminate. 741 00:30:07,705 --> 00:30:11,209 It's four layers of virtually invisible polyester film 742 00:30:11,276 --> 00:30:13,411 that are bonded together to make the window impenetrable. 743 00:30:13,478 --> 00:30:14,345 Helps prevent burglaries. 744 00:30:14,412 --> 00:30:14,412 Was it installed in the Travers' house? 745 00:30:14,412 --> 00:30:17,248 No. 746 00:30:17,315 --> 00:30:18,183 And there was no evidence 747 00:30:18,249 --> 00:30:20,151 of a broken beer bottle anywhere, either. 748 00:30:20,218 --> 00:30:22,287 So the killer must have tracked it in. 749 00:30:22,353 --> 00:30:23,922 I just don't know from where. 750 00:30:23,988 --> 00:30:25,089 Contact the security companies 751 00:30:25,156 --> 00:30:27,192 in the city that install that laminate 752 00:30:27,258 --> 00:30:30,161 and get a list of locations and cross-check them with employees. 753 00:30:30,228 --> 00:30:32,030 You think we might get a hit for Billy Travers? 754 00:30:32,096 --> 00:30:34,265 Maybe. We need to put him in that house. 755 00:30:47,478 --> 00:30:49,981 Yo, man, what's he doing here? 756 00:30:50,048 --> 00:30:53,318 You said that we were gonna sign some sort of cooperation agreement. 757 00:30:53,384 --> 00:30:55,386 Change of plans. 758 00:30:58,256 --> 00:30:59,624 Here we go. 759 00:30:59,691 --> 00:31:01,125 Have a seat. 760 00:31:01,192 --> 00:31:03,628 Go ahead. 761 00:31:03,695 --> 00:31:04,929 You-you talk to Manny? 762 00:31:04,996 --> 00:31:05,930 What did he tell you? 763 00:31:05,997 --> 00:31:07,031 Don't worry about Manny. 764 00:31:07,098 --> 00:31:08,366 He's got his story, you got yours. 765 00:31:08,433 --> 00:31:09,367 You're all good. 766 00:31:09,434 --> 00:31:11,269 As long as you tell the truth, 767 00:31:11,336 --> 00:31:12,470 everything'll be fine. 768 00:31:12,537 --> 00:31:15,073 Wh-What the hell is this thing? 769 00:31:15,139 --> 00:31:16,241 Polygraph. 770 00:31:16,307 --> 00:31:18,876 You giving me a lie detector test? 771 00:31:18,943 --> 00:31:21,479 I mean... aren't those, like, not admissible in court? 772 00:31:21,546 --> 00:31:22,647 They don't always work right. 773 00:31:22,714 --> 00:31:24,349 Eh, only about 98% of the time. 774 00:31:24,415 --> 00:31:25,383 But don't worry about it. 775 00:31:25,450 --> 00:31:27,452 I mean, you're a smart guy, Owen, I can tell. 776 00:31:27,518 --> 00:31:30,221 Even if you're lying, you could beat this machine. 777 00:31:30,288 --> 00:31:31,289 You're gonna do great. 778 00:31:31,356 --> 00:31:34,892 Uh, w-w... wait, wait, wait, where are you going? 779 00:31:34,959 --> 00:31:36,894 I can't give you the test-- I'm not qualified. 780 00:31:36,961 --> 00:31:38,363 We have to bring in an expert. 781 00:31:38,429 --> 00:31:40,298 Ah, here we go. 782 00:31:41,165 --> 00:31:41,165 Take it easy on him. 783 00:31:41,165 --> 00:31:42,000 Mm. 784 00:31:42,000 --> 00:31:42,000 Take it easy on him. 785 00:31:42,000 --> 00:31:42,400 Mm. 786 00:31:45,036 --> 00:31:46,104 (sighs) 787 00:31:46,170 --> 00:31:48,373 Good afternoon... 788 00:31:48,439 --> 00:31:49,674 Mr. Hicks. 789 00:31:49,741 --> 00:31:51,676 Huh. I understand there's a question 790 00:31:51,743 --> 00:31:53,344 to the veracity of certain statements 791 00:31:53,411 --> 00:31:55,380 that you may or may not have made 792 00:31:55,446 --> 00:31:57,115 and/or heard during your confinement 793 00:31:57,181 --> 00:31:59,517 in the fine institution known as Rikers Island. 794 00:31:59,584 --> 00:32:02,253 Is that correct? 795 00:32:02,320 --> 00:32:05,390 I have no idea what the hell you just said, man. 796 00:32:07,258 --> 00:32:09,160 Are you playing games with me, son? 797 00:32:09,227 --> 00:32:10,261 No, I'm not playing games...! 798 00:32:10,328 --> 00:32:13,998 Because any heretofore games will not be tolerated. 799 00:32:14,065 --> 00:32:15,133 Okay? 800 00:32:15,199 --> 00:32:17,001 Mm. 801 00:32:17,769 --> 00:32:20,371 ROSS (over speaker): Now let's get started. 802 00:32:20,438 --> 00:32:23,374 Have you ever been a participant in or administered 803 00:32:23,441 --> 00:32:24,442 any of said polygraph... 804 00:32:24,509 --> 00:32:25,510 How long do you give him? 805 00:32:25,576 --> 00:32:29,347 Well, if Adam remembers to plug the damn thing in, 806 00:32:29,414 --> 00:32:31,316 I don't think he gets past the first question. 807 00:32:31,382 --> 00:32:33,217 First question? 808 00:32:33,284 --> 00:32:34,719 No way it gets that far. 809 00:32:34,786 --> 00:32:36,120 Ten... 810 00:32:37,588 --> 00:32:37,588 This simply measures your blood pressure 811 00:32:37,588 --> 00:32:38,323 ...nine... 812 00:32:38,389 --> 00:32:41,292 while the test is being administered. 813 00:32:41,359 --> 00:32:44,028 The information then relays to the pen thingy 814 00:32:44,095 --> 00:32:46,264 which will go haywire if you're full of... 815 00:32:46,331 --> 00:32:47,432 if you're being untruthful. 816 00:32:47,498 --> 00:32:49,434 And, based on the amount of sweat 817 00:32:49,500 --> 00:32:51,269 that's accumulated on your forehead-- 818 00:32:51,336 --> 00:32:52,403 gross-- 819 00:32:52,470 --> 00:32:54,205 is more than likely. 820 00:32:54,272 --> 00:32:55,406 Ah, now... 821 00:32:56,441 --> 00:32:57,475 This tube, okay, 822 00:32:57,542 --> 00:33:00,244 is going to just go around your chest... 823 00:33:00,311 --> 00:33:01,245 ...two... 824 00:33:02,580 --> 00:33:03,047 ...one. 825 00:33:03,114 --> 00:33:04,449 No, I can't do this! 826 00:33:04,515 --> 00:33:06,050 I'm not gonna do this, man! 827 00:33:06,117 --> 00:33:08,052 He said that we could both help each other out. 828 00:33:08,119 --> 00:33:09,053 Okay, look. 829 00:33:09,120 --> 00:33:10,321 (metal clattering) 830 00:33:10,388 --> 00:33:13,024 Manny said that he had a girlfriend 831 00:33:13,091 --> 00:33:14,125 who lived in Queens, all right? 832 00:33:14,192 --> 00:33:16,594 And he never got to see her because it was too far 833 00:33:16,661 --> 00:33:18,363 from the prison that he was at upstate. 834 00:33:18,429 --> 00:33:20,498 So he said that if he confessed to the murder 835 00:33:20,565 --> 00:33:22,567 of the couple, that that would bring him downstate 836 00:33:22,633 --> 00:33:24,268 for the trial for at least a year. 837 00:33:24,335 --> 00:33:25,770 And then he'd be able to see her. 838 00:33:25,837 --> 00:33:27,338 He said to make it more believable 839 00:33:27,405 --> 00:33:28,473 he'd blab about it to me, 840 00:33:28,539 --> 00:33:29,540 and then I would call the cops 841 00:33:29,607 --> 00:33:31,509 and maybe work out a deal for myself, all right? 842 00:33:31,576 --> 00:33:33,211 That's the truth! 843 00:33:33,277 --> 00:33:35,413 I swear to God, that-that's the truth, man! 844 00:33:35,480 --> 00:33:36,614 Hey, I'm not lying! 845 00:33:36,681 --> 00:33:38,216 I'm telling you, that's the... 846 00:33:38,282 --> 00:33:40,618 (gasping) 847 00:33:44,622 --> 00:33:47,091 If there is a problem, just give me a call. 848 00:33:47,158 --> 00:33:50,561 TAYLOR: I'll take care of it myself. 849 00:33:50,628 --> 00:33:51,629 Thanks. 850 00:34:03,574 --> 00:34:04,542 Hey. 851 00:34:04,609 --> 00:34:05,510 Just dropping off 852 00:34:05,576 --> 00:34:08,446 the DD-5 on Manny Ravarra's false confession. 853 00:34:08,513 --> 00:34:09,547 Defense attorney won't be able 854 00:34:09,614 --> 00:34:11,616 to use him as an alternate theory. 855 00:34:11,681 --> 00:34:13,384 Did you get in touch with the D.A.'s office? 856 00:34:13,451 --> 00:34:15,085 Judge let Billy Travers out on bail. 857 00:34:15,152 --> 00:34:16,286 As of now, 858 00:34:16,353 --> 00:34:17,522 the mother's I.D. 859 00:34:17,588 --> 00:34:18,623 is all we have, 860 00:34:18,688 --> 00:34:19,590 and I'm not even sure we have that. 861 00:34:19,657 --> 00:34:21,626 Should we offer her some kind of protection? 862 00:34:21,692 --> 00:34:22,627 She'll refuse. 863 00:34:22,693 --> 00:34:24,128 She's on her son's side now. 864 00:34:24,195 --> 00:34:25,362 So unless we come up with 865 00:34:25,429 --> 00:34:27,831 a forensic link, he'll be at her bedside by the end of the day. 866 00:34:27,899 --> 00:34:27,899 I'll follow up with Lindsay and Hawkes. 867 00:34:27,899 --> 00:34:29,833 Jo. 868 00:34:29,900 --> 00:34:30,935 Yeah? 869 00:34:31,002 --> 00:34:34,371 If this is gonna work, we got to trust each other. 870 00:34:34,438 --> 00:34:37,608 The DD-5 documenting Grace Travers recanting the I.D.-- 871 00:34:37,675 --> 00:34:40,077 I saw you looking at it. 872 00:34:40,710 --> 00:34:41,545 Damaging to the case-- 873 00:34:41,612 --> 00:34:43,547 you thought maybe I wouldn't file it? 874 00:34:43,614 --> 00:34:46,317 History has a tendency of repeating itself. 875 00:34:46,384 --> 00:34:49,120 What happened in D.C. is not a part of my history. 876 00:34:50,254 --> 00:34:52,389 Uncovering mistakes made by your lab 877 00:34:52,456 --> 00:34:55,426 and alerting defense counsel was part of your oath. 878 00:34:55,493 --> 00:34:56,460 Still is. 879 00:34:56,527 --> 00:34:58,129 Tell that to Senator Matthews. 880 00:34:58,196 --> 00:35:00,097 I still get letters from him blaming me 881 00:35:00,164 --> 00:35:02,133 for the outcome of his daughter's case. 882 00:35:07,238 --> 00:35:09,440 The mistake I uncovered 883 00:35:09,507 --> 00:35:12,210 was made by a guy named Frank Waters. 884 00:35:12,276 --> 00:35:14,312 Impeccable reputation. 885 00:35:14,378 --> 00:35:17,215 I worked with Frank Waters for 12 years, Mac. 886 00:35:17,281 --> 00:35:18,716 I went to his wedding, 887 00:35:18,783 --> 00:35:21,185 his kids' birthdays. 888 00:35:21,252 --> 00:35:23,621 So when I discovered he destroyed a document 889 00:35:23,688 --> 00:35:26,457 detailing a mistake he made interpreting DNA results, 890 00:35:26,524 --> 00:35:28,292 two things happened that day: 891 00:35:28,359 --> 00:35:31,329 trust became just another word 892 00:35:31,395 --> 00:35:33,598 and Serena Matthews' rapist went free. 893 00:35:33,664 --> 00:35:35,500 You had to make it public. 894 00:35:35,566 --> 00:35:37,235 It was a decision I don't regret making, 895 00:35:37,301 --> 00:35:38,402 and I'd make it again. 896 00:35:41,973 --> 00:35:45,476 Jo, my team does not sacrifice integrity 897 00:35:45,543 --> 00:35:46,911 for a desired result. 898 00:35:46,978 --> 00:35:48,913 Now that you're part of it, 899 00:35:48,980 --> 00:35:50,681 I promise you you'll never have to make 900 00:35:50,748 --> 00:35:52,550 that kind of decision again, okay? 901 00:35:56,721 --> 00:35:57,722 Hey. There are four companies 902 00:35:57,788 --> 00:36:00,391 in the city that manufacture 903 00:36:00,458 --> 00:36:02,393 the security laminate I found on the shards in the vic's bed. 904 00:36:02,460 --> 00:36:04,195 One of them installed the laminate 905 00:36:04,262 --> 00:36:05,930 for something called Glassphemy. 906 00:36:05,997 --> 00:36:07,632 Oh, I read about that in the paper. 907 00:36:07,698 --> 00:36:08,733 It's an art installation 908 00:36:08,799 --> 00:36:10,268 where people get out their aggression 909 00:36:10,334 --> 00:36:11,636 by hurling bottles into a glass cage 910 00:36:11,702 --> 00:36:14,238 and the company collects the shards and recycles them. 911 00:36:15,373 --> 00:36:16,707 I might need to try that. 912 00:36:16,774 --> 00:36:17,675 (chuckles) 913 00:36:17,742 --> 00:36:19,610 They use the polyester laminate on the cage 914 00:36:19,677 --> 00:36:20,878 to keep it from breaking. 915 00:36:20,945 --> 00:36:23,948 So a piece of the laminate was transferred to a shard of glass, 916 00:36:24,015 --> 00:36:25,683 which came in contact with our killer. 917 00:36:25,750 --> 00:36:26,684 DANVILLE: And the killer 918 00:36:26,751 --> 00:36:27,718 transferred it to the bed. 919 00:36:27,785 --> 00:36:29,687 Glassphemy uses an outside company, 920 00:36:29,754 --> 00:36:32,690 Brookston Recycling, to pulverize the shards. 921 00:36:32,757 --> 00:36:35,459 So I got a list of their employees. 922 00:36:35,526 --> 00:36:37,495 This guy is particularly interesting. 923 00:36:38,362 --> 00:36:40,398 Paul Benson. Who is he? 924 00:36:40,464 --> 00:36:42,400 He was released a week ago from Hudson Correctional. 925 00:36:42,466 --> 00:36:43,701 He served eight years for rape. 926 00:36:43,768 --> 00:36:45,503 What's his connection to the case? 927 00:36:45,570 --> 00:36:47,471 He grew up in the victims' house. 928 00:36:58,349 --> 00:37:00,785 (techno music playing, crowd chattering, laughing) 929 00:37:30,748 --> 00:37:33,250 ♪ ♪ 930 00:37:46,731 --> 00:37:46,731 See him? 931 00:37:46,731 --> 00:37:47,398 Go. 932 00:37:48,733 --> 00:37:49,667 Move! Move! 933 00:37:56,841 --> 00:37:58,409 He's up there. You see him up there? 934 00:38:06,651 --> 00:38:08,285 (grunts) 935 00:38:11,922 --> 00:38:13,290 (grunting, glass shatters) 936 00:38:15,693 --> 00:38:16,861 Stay down! 937 00:38:16,927 --> 00:38:18,362 I got him! I got him! 938 00:38:18,429 --> 00:38:19,497 Don't move. 939 00:38:19,563 --> 00:38:19,563 (handcuffs clicking) 940 00:38:19,563 --> 00:38:21,399 Right there. 941 00:38:21,465 --> 00:38:24,735 Stay down. Stay down. 942 00:38:24,802 --> 00:38:26,437 Did you hear from Hawkes? 943 00:38:26,504 --> 00:38:28,506 Yep. Just enough dirt under Paul Benson's shoes 944 00:38:28,572 --> 00:38:30,574 to match the soil at the crime scene. 945 00:38:32,977 --> 00:38:34,779 I don't get it. 946 00:38:34,845 --> 00:38:36,580 This guy was the senior class president, 947 00:38:36,647 --> 00:38:37,782 captain of the soccer team, 948 00:38:37,848 --> 00:38:39,784 dean's list. 949 00:38:39,850 --> 00:38:41,652 This kid had everything going for him back in 2002. 950 00:38:41,719 --> 00:38:43,387 He was the guy you love to hate 951 00:38:43,454 --> 00:38:45,523 in every John Hughes film. 952 00:38:45,589 --> 00:38:47,892 He was even dating the prom queen, Sarah Dufresne. 953 00:38:47,958 --> 00:38:49,794 Apparently dating her wasn't enough. 954 00:38:49,860 --> 00:38:51,762 "I told him I wanted to wait, 955 00:38:51,829 --> 00:38:54,832 "that if he loved me, he would respect that I wanted to wait. 956 00:38:54,899 --> 00:38:57,802 He grabbed my arms and pinned me down." 957 00:38:57,868 --> 00:38:59,937 One minute he's Harvard bound, next he's Rikers bound. 958 00:39:00,004 --> 00:39:01,539 Did eight years. 959 00:39:01,605 --> 00:39:02,873 Got out week and a half ago. 960 00:39:02,940 --> 00:39:04,875 Based on the case file, doesn't look like 961 00:39:04,942 --> 00:39:06,811 we had anything beyond her statement. 962 00:39:06,877 --> 00:39:09,113 He claimed it was consensual. 963 00:39:09,180 --> 00:39:10,848 Classic he said/she said? 964 00:39:10,915 --> 00:39:12,683 Not quite. 965 00:39:17,788 --> 00:39:19,557 His parents testified against him. 966 00:39:20,658 --> 00:39:22,126 STEVEN: Not a day goes by 967 00:39:22,193 --> 00:39:23,794 we don't second-guess our decision. 968 00:39:23,861 --> 00:39:25,429 Paul's our son. 969 00:39:25,496 --> 00:39:26,897 If you'd kept silent, you wouldn't have been able 970 00:39:26,964 --> 00:39:27,898 to live with yourselves. 971 00:39:27,965 --> 00:39:29,867 NINA: Paul was a good kid. 972 00:39:29,934 --> 00:39:31,736 Had so much going for him. 973 00:39:31,802 --> 00:39:33,504 He came home that night and we immediately knew 974 00:39:33,571 --> 00:39:34,805 something was wrong. 975 00:39:37,208 --> 00:39:38,542 NINA: Paul? 976 00:39:38,609 --> 00:39:39,877 Paul, 977 00:39:39,944 --> 00:39:41,378 what's wrong? 978 00:39:41,912 --> 00:39:43,447 Where's Sarah? 979 00:39:48,018 --> 00:39:50,454 What happened, Paul? 980 00:39:50,521 --> 00:39:51,889 Whatever it is, you can tell us. 981 00:39:51,956 --> 00:39:52,923 NINA: When he told us, 982 00:39:52,990 --> 00:39:55,593 all I could see was Sarah's face. 983 00:39:55,659 --> 00:39:57,428 And what she must have been going through. 984 00:39:57,495 --> 00:39:58,696 STEVEN: And her parents-- 985 00:39:58,763 --> 00:39:59,797 we'd known them for years. 986 00:39:59,864 --> 00:40:02,566 Sarah obviously went to the police 987 00:40:02,633 --> 00:40:03,734 and they arrested Paul. 988 00:40:03,801 --> 00:40:05,169 When the prosecutor asked 989 00:40:05,236 --> 00:40:06,704 for our cooperation, 990 00:40:06,771 --> 00:40:09,907 it took a few weeks and several fights, 991 00:40:09,974 --> 00:40:12,877 but we decided that telling the truth was the right thing to do. 992 00:40:12,943 --> 00:40:14,879 It was. 993 00:40:14,945 --> 00:40:16,814 No matter how much it may have hurt. 994 00:40:17,982 --> 00:40:19,884 So you had no contact with Paul after that? 995 00:40:19,950 --> 00:40:21,886 STEVEN: We tried, 996 00:40:21,952 --> 00:40:23,654 but Paul didn't want anything to do with us. 997 00:40:23,721 --> 00:40:25,656 He felt that we'd betrayed him, 998 00:40:25,723 --> 00:40:27,491 so he just cut us off. 999 00:40:27,558 --> 00:40:29,560 We moved a couple years later. 1000 00:40:29,627 --> 00:40:31,028 Tried to put it behind us. 1001 00:40:35,266 --> 00:40:38,936 Paul was digging by the side of the house for the spare key. 1002 00:40:39,003 --> 00:40:40,771 But the locks had been changed, 1003 00:40:40,838 --> 00:40:42,740 and he used a crowbar to get inside. 1004 00:40:48,979 --> 00:40:50,948 He thought it was you in that bed. 1005 00:40:51,015 --> 00:40:54,018 Paul went back to the house to kill you. 1006 00:41:04,995 --> 00:41:07,998 TAYLOR: You didn't know your parents had moved. 1007 00:41:08,065 --> 00:41:11,068 You had no contact with them ever since you went away. 1008 00:41:13,771 --> 00:41:15,940 What were you thinking, Paul? 1009 00:41:16,006 --> 00:41:17,074 You were getting even? 1010 00:41:17,141 --> 00:41:19,009 That killing your parents 1011 00:41:19,076 --> 00:41:21,078 was somehow gonna settle the score 1012 00:41:21,145 --> 00:41:22,680 for them testifying against you? 1013 00:41:22,746 --> 00:41:23,747 I was just a kid. 1014 00:41:23,814 --> 00:41:24,815 You were 18 years old. 1015 00:41:24,882 --> 00:41:25,749 You were old enough 1016 00:41:25,816 --> 00:41:27,618 to be held accountable for your actions. 1017 00:41:27,685 --> 00:41:29,920 They betrayed me. 1018 00:41:29,987 --> 00:41:31,021 No, no. 1019 00:41:31,088 --> 00:41:33,824 You betrayed them. 1020 00:41:35,092 --> 00:41:35,860 You think it was easy 1021 00:41:35,926 --> 00:41:37,895 for your parents to do what they did? 1022 00:41:39,630 --> 00:41:40,631 Your girlfriend, Sarah-- 1023 00:41:40,698 --> 00:41:42,800 they were just supposed to let her go through life 1024 00:41:42,867 --> 00:41:44,535 knowing you raped her and got away with it? 1025 00:41:48,606 --> 00:41:51,775 The woman who went to the hospital... 1026 00:41:51,842 --> 00:41:53,510 she survived? 1027 00:41:54,845 --> 00:41:55,846 She's gonna be okay? 1028 00:41:55,913 --> 00:41:56,847 No. 1029 00:41:56,914 --> 00:41:58,015 She lost her husband, 1030 00:41:58,082 --> 00:42:00,050 her son lost his father, and she's gonna have 1031 00:42:00,117 --> 00:42:01,852 permanent brain damage. 1032 00:42:01,919 --> 00:42:04,822 So, no, she's not gonna be okay. 1033 00:42:07,825 --> 00:42:09,660 You had an opportunity to get out 1034 00:42:09,727 --> 00:42:11,061 and make something of your life, Paul. 1035 00:42:12,930 --> 00:42:15,532 Instead, you destroyed another family. 1036 00:42:33,183 --> 00:42:35,552 (monitor beeping rhythmically) 1037 00:42:37,121 --> 00:42:38,689 (quiet knocking) 1038 00:42:39,890 --> 00:42:41,926 Mind if I come in for a moment? 1039 00:42:46,997 --> 00:42:49,166 How's she doing? 1040 00:42:49,233 --> 00:42:51,035 All right, I guess. 1041 00:42:51,101 --> 00:42:52,336 Doctor said she should 1042 00:42:52,403 --> 00:42:52,403 be able to leave in a few days. 1043 00:42:52,403 --> 00:42:54,000 Good. 1044 00:42:54,000 --> 00:42:54,000 be able to leave in a few days. 1045 00:42:54,000 --> 00:42:54,038 Good. 1046 00:42:54,104 --> 00:42:55,572 I'm glad to hear that. 1047 00:42:59,843 --> 00:43:02,112 I'm sorry you had to go through that, Billy. 1048 00:43:02,179 --> 00:43:04,181 Yeah. 1049 00:43:04,248 --> 00:43:06,183 I get it. 1050 00:43:06,250 --> 00:43:08,052 You were just doing your job, I guess. 1051 00:43:08,118 --> 00:43:12,122 You know, sometimes we lose sight of 1052 00:43:12,189 --> 00:43:14,591 how hard it is to be called a suspect. 1053 00:43:23,167 --> 00:43:27,671 Look, if you ever need anything, I hope you'll give me a call. 1054 00:43:31,141 --> 00:43:32,876 GRACE: Billy. 1055 00:43:32,943 --> 00:43:35,713 Who's this? 1056 00:43:36,847 --> 00:43:39,616 My name is Mac Taylor. 1057 00:43:41,452 --> 00:43:43,620 Have you met my son Billy? 1058 00:43:43,687 --> 00:43:44,455 TAYLOR: I have. 1059 00:43:44,521 --> 00:43:47,825 You have a good son, Mrs. Travers. 1060 00:43:50,294 --> 00:43:52,629 You're a very lucky woman. 1061 00:43:54,231 --> 00:43:58,168 Captioning sponsored by CBS, 1062 00:43:58,235 --> 00:44:00,237 CSI NY PRODUCTIONS, 1063 00:44:06,310 --> 00:44:08,645 Captioned by access.wgbh.org oup at WGBH